Philosophical and Historical Aspects of Advanced Computing Algorithms
Introductory note: Because of the complete absence of meaning due to easily demonstrable absurdity, the author of this text refuses to use the scientifically ungrounded, philosophically incorrect and above all pretentious coinage "artificial intelligence".
Explanation of the note: In the world there are only two kinds of things/beings, whether material or non-material: natural and artificial. Natural ones we find already present in our surroundings when we come into this world, and we in no way participate in their creation. Artificial things are those things that man has made, is making, and will make. Intelligence is something already given; it is a term that describes a property of a natural phenomenon. Adding the adjective "artificial" in front of a term that defines a natural, given phenomenon is boldly pretentious, irresponsible and unfounded in elementary logic. Thus the term "artificial intelligence" is absurd in the same way as the terms "artificial air", "artificial water", "artificial Sun" or "artificial God". The author of this text has heard of the term "artificial snow", but has also had the personal opportunity to confirm that it is – in fact not snow.
For that reason, without any attempt to deal with the name of this segment of the development of technology, and exclusively for the purposes of this text, I shall use the term Advanced Computer Algorithms, which in the broadest sense gives grounds for a more accurate and precise description of the phenomenon considered in the text.
Reflection and responsible consideration of the civilizational-technological phenomenon of Advanced Computer Algorithms (hereinafter: ACA), outside the context of the philosophical-scientific-technological foundation of the civilization that gave birth to this phenomenon, is wrong and from the outset condemned to incompleteness. Placing any phenomenon exclusively in the context of the "given situation", without a complete understanding of its genesis, cannot in any way yield a remotely valid prediction of what that phenomenon may bring about. This common-sense thesis could also be proved on the logical level, but we shall not deal with that here.
The philosophical-ontological framework is the basis of any system, and this text uses the term "system" in the broadest sense of the word. Everything is a system, from stable quantum structures to the Universe. Ontology defines the system. The analogy with the foundations of a building is complete: Ontology, as the foundation of science, entirely defines its whole "arrangement of rooms", "load-bearing walls", even the height to which one can build such a system. The ontology on which today's science is based, and hence also this "high-tech" civilization of ours, as we like to flatter ourselves, is called Cartesianism. Cartesianism is the philosophical source and framework out of which flow and within which are framed practically all the thought processes of the average member of this civilization. All our scientific reflections start exclusively from the Cartesian basis and move exclusively within that ontological frame. Thus every reflection, on any topic, of every member of this civilization, more or less — and mostly entirely — is conditioned by the Cartesian way of looking at the world. Our civilization is Cartesian, our science is Cartesian, our technology is Cartesian, and "artificial intelligence" is the same. Exclusively. Otherwise, when things are properly understood — it cannot be.
So, Cartesianism, which is barely 400 years old, has become the source of all the thoughts and views on nature of Western civilization, the foundation from which one starts to build science, which then participates in building the individual by communicating to him the scientific truths and expert advice on which that same individual bases his thoughts, decisions and actions. Such an individual, thus established, from the conditioning so formed conceives reality and influences his environment, further reinforcing the general conditioning by the Cartesian view of the world. The circle is closed, and it is a circle in which we are spinning as a civilization — ever faster, it might be said. A key concept, an essential concept, an epochal concept. In fact, no adjective is strong enough or excessive to describe the importance of what lies hidden behind the concept of Cartesianism.
If Cartesianism is so important — someone might think at this point — how is it possible that it is not spoken of in public, that it is not taught in schools, that time and human resources are not devoted to studying, understanding and reconsidering something of such essential importance for every human being, his immediate and wider environment, and hence for civilization as a whole? And indeed, the question is entirely logical, even essential.
The situation, of course, is such that none of this happens. If someone has even heard of the concept of Cartesianism, in all likelihood he will not be able to explain to you what it is about. To make the absurdity inevitable and final, our celebrated school system does its part by producing scientists who are the ultimate and all-powerful bulwark of Cartesianism, and to whom Cartesianism during the process of education is not so much as mentioned in passing, let alone seriously reflected upon or studied.
We people, members of Western civilization, are subjected to a process of complete conditioning by the Cartesian view of the world from the moment we appear on this planet. Every one of us, without exception. The complete worldview, the narratives communicated to us in the family, and the whole school system are based on it, flow from it, and yet in no way engage with it. Cartesianism in our civilization is taken for granted. People are conditioned to take it for granted that it must be so, and that on that level, the level of ontology, there is nothing to question or think about.
Such a state of affairs is logical, once we understand that, let us repeat, absolutely each of us is entirely bounded by the Cartesian philosophical framework. Criticism of Cartesianism is criticism of oneself, of the adopted "normalcy" of one's way of thinking and view of the world; criticism of the root of all sciences, of all official paradigms, and hence criticism of the very foundations of our civilization. And these are not topics addressed in the process of obtaining a degree and continuing a successful scientific career. Simply — that is where one starts, such a view of the world is taken for granted, all thought currents flow from there, all thoughts are conditioned by it.
A conditioned mind cannot free itself from its conditioning, because it would thereby automatically cease to be conditioned. This sentence, absurd as it may sound in its logic, is in fact true. The conditioned mind is actively and entirely occupied with maintaining its conditioning, because conditioning implies precisely that it should be as it is, and in no other way. We are all programmed, and our operating system, in which we run various user programs and play games, is called Cartesianism.
At this point we should not misunderstand that common sources from which everything starts do not exist or should not exist. We come into this world in order that certain traditions, wisdoms, learnings, understandings of people who spent their lives on this planet before us should be handed down to us, so that we may set out from them into our own life and creation. Certainly the idea is not that every new human being should start from complete zero, without adopting the knowledge and skills already gained by previous generations. The very essence of building civilization is precisely that — where I left off, you continue. Such initial knowledge and philosophical-ontological frameworks for looking at nature have always existed and still exist, and are passed down through generations thousands of years back, some probably significantly longer. It is truly strange that our civilization has entirely surrendered itself to a philosophical system established less than 400 years ago, one that is completely opposed to all the "old knowledge", written traces of which available to our civilization go thousands of years back, exhibiting multi-millennial consistency and extension in practically all previous civilizations and social systems.
If we start from the Vedas, as the oldest philosophical system available to us, it is easy to see that the entire Ontology of reality of that philosophical system is based on something denoted in Sanskrit by the term Tribhuvana. Three Beings, one might translate it into our language, close to Sanskrit, because that is precisely what it is about. Behind this concept lies the understanding that the whole world, reality, Universe – is three-united, and that, in the ontological sense, it consists of THREE worlds, three mutually completely permeating wholes. Philosophy, Mathematics and Physics – three sciences; a fourth simply does not exist, all other sciences are derived from these three primary disciplines. Spirit, Soul and Body. The trace of this Three-united/Tripartite ontology is very clear throughout history, even as it is currently available to us. From Pythagoras through Plato, our ancestors from somewhat more southern regions clearly reflected on and held to Three-united ontology as the only valid one. Plato, who lived in pre-Christian times (427 – 347 BC), left behind a clear ontological system of three levels of the functioning of reality:
- Source of manifestation: Primary, Primordial, Original
- Non-material manifestation: At the level of physics the notion of Field is introduced here. At the level of human existence, Plato at this point introduces the term Psyche (ψυχή), whose one original meaning is the notion of the Soul.
- Material manifestation: Phenomenal / Material / Physical / Corporeal
When you have set up in a given ontology the basic wholes of the system you deal with, further considerations are directed to the relations between those wholes and the ways of their functioning. At the entrance to Plato's Academy it was written: "Let no one enter who does not understand Geometry." To understand Geometry meant for Plato to have a complete grasp of two fundamental things. The first is understanding that Everything is Geometry, expressed through relations, symmetries and similar abstract notions from which the whole manifestation, both material and non-material, is conceived and composed. The second is the understanding that Geometry is conceived on the "highest" level of Existence, in the Primary/Primordial/Original. Thus the entire thought process of us human beings, which can be described on many levels by geometric images and relations, is conceived outside our physical/corporeal reality, in the primordial domain. Consciousness is primary and precedes matter, not the other way round. There is the Source of everything, of the complete geometry, both on the material and on the psychic/mental level of human existence. If that was not clear to you, Plato did not want you in his Academy.
Thus, in the Tripartite scientific ontology one assumes the existence of a Primary energy field, whose setting in motion consequently forms the complete non-material (all subsequently derived physical fields) and material manifestation. After such a "movement in the primary", hierarchically speaking, first the non-material aspect of appearance is manifested, and only after it the material/corporeal. That primary movement in the Primordial energy structure our science notices, christening it with the charming term "Quantum foam". At the level of physics, in the current vocabulary, fields precede matter, i.e. matter is the consequence of the distribution of energy states in the fields. Of course the connections between levels are mutual and reciprocal, so that in that sense, matter, once formed, influences the distribution of energy flows in the fields; but this does not change the fact that the primary path of Existence is "from top to bottom", from the primary, through the non-material to the material.
At the level of human existence, every human idea and thought is conceived through a movement in the Primary and "descended" from there onto the psychic level. That is the level of cognition, the level of emotions, dreams, ideas, imagination, and the entire set of electromagnetic and other radiations which at every moment we all receive and emit. That is therefore the level of the non-material part of our manifestation, which de facto exists, and which is manifested as the Continuity of the inner life of each of you reading this — that unique form of appearance which each of us has individually within, and with which as a rule we entirely identify, and which is in no way material. It, however, is in a coupled relationship with the material level of appearance, but the psyche as such is not a material but exclusively a non-material natural phenomenon.
This level is sometimes also called intermediary, whereby the mediation refers to the connection between the Primary and the Material. In the science based on this kind of ontology, at this level the notion of Fields of potential is introduced, both scalar (electric) and vector (magnetic), which Maxwell postulated, and in which as yet no physical forces acting on material bodies appear.
So, in the Tripartite ontological setting, the precondition for the realization of any form or action on the material level is the conception of primary information at the Original level. The primary information so conceived is first manifested on the non-material level, which in the case of human existence would be everything that goes on in the psychic domain of the individual. Therefore, any artificial thing, everything that man has ever created, first had to arise as a thought, idea, number, geometry, image on the psychic level of some individual. Only after that is a material manifestation of artificial things possible.
At the hierarchically lowest, material level, science introduces the notion of Vector fields of force, by which the states and dynamics of physical, material systems are described. Today's science deals almost exclusively with precisely that level – matter, and the electric, magnetic and gravitational forces which affect the material world around us and the relations within it.
For the sake of the point, I shall repeat once again: In this world there are only two kinds of things — Natural and Artificial. Natural ones (tree, water, air, earth...), we humans find upon our arrival on this planet; they are "lowered" onto the corporeal level from the Source. Artificial ones we humans make — but again through the same process — from an Original movement, a perturbation within the Primordial, through the movement of the human psyche in the form of an idea or thought, to the final movement on the physical plane. Always three, and the primary flow is always from the Source. But of course what you do with the flow, especially in places close to the Source, has to do also with the Source itself — all connections between the parts of the Tripartite ontological system are mutual and reciprocal. The vertical Primary – Non-material – Material is the path of movement in a system based on Tripartite ontology: the primary function of our Psyche/Soul is connection with the Source, with the Divine. That way, and no other, has the whole matter been passed on to new generations and interpreted for eons back. All the stories have been told in that way. Plato only tightened the whole matter and handed it down to us well preserved and terminologically set out.
In Plato's time, slightly older than him, there lived a philosopher/thinker who remained remembered under the name Democritus (c. 460 – c. 370 BC). Democritus completely rejected Tripartiteness and subjected the creation of the Universe to the following ontological setup: Nothing but atoms (the smallest, indivisible) and the void exists, and phenomenal reality is formed by the grouping of atoms within that same void. Thus creation is carried out not from above, by a vertical that establishes clear relations between the three parts of one whole, but from below, from the finer to the coarser. Democritus thought and wrote in that way, and this was continued directly by probably the last important Athenian philosopher Epicurus (341 – 270 BC). After Epicurus, such an ontological framework, which had no place in the philosophical thought of the rising Christianity, was for the next nearly 2000 years regarded by the philosophically informed world as the ultimate philosophical heresy. Right up to the appearance of Descartes.
René Descartes (1596 – 1650)
A Frenchman. I think, therefore I am. He was a brilliant mind indeed, interested in everything, hungry for knowledge and understanding. The dark Middle Ages, that incredible period in the development of humanity about which unspeakable historical stories are told, was over. In European countries humanism began, and after it the Renaissance. Thinkers interested in understanding and explaining natural phenomena were sprouting up like mushrooms after the rain.
In his works, Descartes clearly states that all existence again necessarily consists of three different substances, as he called them, each having its essence, using the following terminology: God, who possesses necessary existence; Mind, which possesses self-aware thought; Matter, which exists in three dimensions. So, he thought that way, wrote that way. But his need for rational cognition (and exclusively that) gave him no rest, so he began, through a process of radical doubt, to think about how this material, truly intriguing world had actually come about.
He was led by the basic logic, very easy, clear and palatable for human reason, that any material thing, however complex, we can by some procedures and with the application of the right technology take apart into ever finer and finer parts, and then by analysis of those parts continue on in the process of understanding the whole. Forming a rational-logical basis in that way, Descartes was very much ready to accept the Democritean-Atomistic view of the world. All that had to happen was for someone with such an ontology, of which he could have heard nothing during his intensive youthful schooling in the Jesuit school, to acquaint him with it.
That is precisely what today the little-mentioned Dutchman Isaac Beeckman (1588 – 1637) did, during Descartes' stay in the Dutch town of Breda, in his twenties. And so Descartes, grounded in complete skepticism towards everything that is not the "I That Thinks", entirely ready to unscrew the universe into its finest parts in order to try to understand the whole exclusively through reason, duly armed with the acquired information about the atomistic view of the world, at one moment came out publicly with essentially Democritus' idea that "indivisible balls" through their union form a whole. But, since he was a serious man who knew how to grapple with the essence itself, he could not leave the whole matter merely at that level. This ontological position had to be further elaborated and supported, and this Descartes undertook, in a very interesting, even incredible way.
The object of Ontology in classical philosophy
The object of Ontology in classical philosophy is Being, which in the text so far we have denoted by the general term System. The simplest and surprisingly precise definition of Being is that it is an Indivisible Whole. Three-united ontology entails the understanding that every Being, with all its qualities which spring from itself as Indivisible Whole, on the corporeal level, as we have already noted, appears from the Primary. Vertical causality is the term used to describe the position that everything is conceived in the Original — that the cause of everything is always in the vertical, i.e. that all forms of non-material and material manifestation always and exclusively have their cause in the Primary/Original.
I, as a human being, possess my quality of Indivisible Whole which, as such, I manifest both on the material and on the non-material level. The state of a being changes at every moment (my hair is falling out, I am evaporating always and everywhere, my beard itches, I am awake or asleep, I feel joy or sorrow) – but in that one and only, present moment, all quality springs from the given state of the being as Indivisible Whole, not depending on anything else. Thus, the rose as Being looks the way it looks, smells the way it smells, and is red exclusively and only as the Indivisible Whole of what it is. Pluck the petals of the flower or observe it at some other moment, and it will possess altered qualities, but still remain an Indivisible Whole. Being is a flow in the existence/duration of its own Indivisible Whole, whose qualities in time change under the influence of the environment and the passage of time.
Such an ontological understanding of the process of arising and manifestation of the qualities of Being in the phenomenal world inevitably contains the tenet that the Whole can never be understood as a set of its own parts. Or, put differently: The Quality of the Whole can in no way be fully and correctly understood through the process of analysis of its Parts. Such an ontological setup is in complete opposition to the Cartesian, and hence today's scientific way of looking at the world. In the Three-united ontological setup it is clear that such a thing is impossible, and science is not approached in that way. The Whole is more than the sum of its Parts. The sum of Parts is less than the Whole. Cognition proceeds from above, through the vertical, from the Primary to the Corporeal. The primary scientific method based on such ontology is not today's generally accepted inductive one, which moves from the individual to the general, but the deductive one, which moves from the general to the individual. The quality of Being is exclusively tied to the concept and state of Being as Indivisible Whole. In such an ontology, understanding cannot be approached from below, from the parts. It therefore is not even attempted, because it is ontologically meaningless. Understanding must include awareness of the existence of the vertical, of vertical causality and of the mutual relations of every Being/Natural system as Indivisible Whole and the Source from which that Whole springs, and with which it is at every moment in interaction. Creation moves "from top to bottom", from the primary, through the intermediary, to the material, while what is "below" can also influence creation through feedback processes which within human existence take place through the intermediary level of the Psyche.
In the Cartesian way of looking at the world, which is based on Descartes' at the very least problematic reflections and conclusions on how nature functions (it is the second syllable of the surname Descartes (in the original: DesCartes) that has been used as a basis for naming this ontological setup), things stand diametrically opposite. The arising of any phenomenon – Being, depends exclusively on material, indivisible parts that enter into relations and build Being. The way they combine is alone responsible for the quality of Being. Being is nothing other than a set of material entities (today's science uses the term Particles), which by their random combining, through the game of large numbers over a necessarily long span of time, unite in various forms and finally form Life and Consciousness. In such a view of the world, matter precedes the phenomenon of Consciousness, which is regarded as an accidentally "triggered" energy state arising from an essentially meaningless game at the material level. Precisely this is the basis of all the harrowing, "scientifically grounded" transhumanist schools of thought that are today so aggressively imposed: if matter has accidentally formed consciousness through some evolutionary processes, then indeed there is no philosophical obstacle to that same matter-based consciousness continuing to improve itself through the application of exclusively material technologies. A chip in the head, so that the head thinks better – and off we go, to new labour victories, because what is there to talk about, everything is anyway exclusively material and meaningless. Just as contemporary Cartesian science has been persistently and consistently telling us for more than a century. And science must be believed, must it not? There is no primary, no providence, no vertical causality, Cartesianism does not go in that direction. It remains all the time in the horizontal, dealing exclusively with the space-time causality of the material level, not requiring any primary providence in all of it. Precisely this Cartesian premise is the starting point of the complete and inevitable separation of Western science and civilization from God, which was carried out in the 19th and completed in the 20th century.
On the question of the qualities of being, Democritus says: "By convention sweet, by convention bitter, by convention hot, by convention cold, by convention colour: but in reality – atoms and space." With such an ontological position, Being as an Indivisible Whole is at once abolished, together with all its qualities that flow from that whole. Being does not possess quality in itself; quality is entirely and exclusively formed in the consciousness of the observer, through the process of sensory perception. Epicurus goes a step further and, surprisingly precisely from the standpoint of today's materialist science, defines sensory perceptions as "fine material imprints or little pictures that peel off from objects, fly with extraordinary ease and speed through the air and through the void enter our sense organs, where they trigger reflections of the external world".
I think, therefore I am. Although in a very subtle way, in the Cartesian ontology even more so applies: I think, therefore you are. Cartesianism entirely conditions all the belonging qualities of every being on the existence of a consciousness of the observer, which is capable of perceiving. The existence of any being, of any material thing with all its qualities, Descartes essentially conditions on the existence of the Self. At that point there occurred a total and irrevocable separation into My inner continuity of life (Res Cogitans) and Everything else outside Me, including even my physical body (Res Extensa). In that way we all observe the world, because we are so conditioned – Cartesianism tells us that things function that way, and we unquestioningly believe it. I am I, and Everything else is Everything else. Nothing beyond horizontal causality embodied in chance exists, there is no vertical, and hence no Primary Source, or any kind of Divine providence. Every man for himself, in himself, upon himself and under himself, for man is a wolf to man. A civilization of frightened and feral Ego floating in a collective Psychosis – that is what we currently live in. The source of such a situation in which our civilization de facto finds itself lies precisely in this point of leverage of the Cartesian view of the world.
By introducing the above philosophical premises into Cartesianism, the existence of any vertical is completely nullified, everything is lowered exclusively to the corporeal level, on a at the very least debatable philosophical setup that by analysis of the parts one can arrive at the understanding of the quality of Being/System as a whole. Cartesianism is responsible for the complete barrenness of today's exclusively quantitative-materialist science, which is not even aware of the inherent quality of Being as Indivisible Whole. Precisely for this reason there is no substantive, qualitative understanding of any physical concept today in science — we do not know what gravity is, what electricity is, what magnetism is, what current is, what inertia is. Nothing is clear to us. We can break everything down, disassemble and measure it; on the level of quantity we get by well. But qualitative understandings there are absolutely none, nowhere. Nothing but a pile of self-sufficient speculations/theories and outdated ideas and setups slowly entering the second century of their barren scientific existence. When things are subjected to the ontological analysis presented, it is clear that it cannot be otherwise, nor ever will be, so long as Cartesianism has any say. And it does have a say!
For today's scientist, any being/system is nothing other than a collection of various atoms, of carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, sodium... which in their mutual relations and motion in the void/space become the source of mechanical and electromagnetic vibrations which we humans feel with our senses and detect with instruments. And only when our senses receive the vibrations that reach us from that grey, external world of quantity, which in itself possesses absolutely no inherent quality, in the darkness of our skulls, through the material game of neuronal currents, in our consciousness produced by the material system called the brain(!?), a reality is formed in which the flower has a fragrance and is red. In the real world – none of that exists! There is no fragrance, no colours, nothing. Only something outside Me, to which Me, in my consciousness, gives the form of quality. The Source is displaced from God's providence by Cartesianism to the level of the chance play of the joining of particles, which plays out on the principle of large numbers and over a long span of time. It is not God who bestows quality; quality is formed in our consciousness and without it does not exist. The Self thereby completely separates itself from the whole. In Cartesian ontology, God, the primary providence, does not have to exist at all; it is simply not taken into account in the process of reductionist cognition. Of course, this is precisely why that same God is at all absent from today's science. It cannot be otherwise, because the ontological foundation of science is so set up. And the foundation, as we have already said, determines absolutely everything in further building. The foundation is a serious matter; one should not play with foundations lightly.
The philosophical term denoting this moment of introducing the element of schizophrenia into the philosophical foundation of our civilization is Bifurcation, a term brought into practice at this place, precisely at the moment of the complete "seizure" of science by Cartesianism in the first half of the 20th century, by the eminent English philosopher Alfred Whitehead (1861 – 1947). The ultimate unhooking from the Vertical and the Whole. No vertical, and hence no Primary source, exists in Cartesianism. That is the foundation of Cartesianism, and hence of all of us who are conditioned by it, weaned on it and equipped with it as the information with which we approach all reflections on this world. One simply does not think about it – yes, of course no vertical exists at all, psychology as a Cartesian science cannot recognize the notion of soul, and no intermediary levels are in play in this civilization. God is in the museum, and materialist science rampages in its helplessness within the philosophical frame in which it is compressed and shackled, trying to assemble a whole out of parts, to reach quality through quantity, in which it does not succeed at all. This is no joke, these are serious matters! With such matters serious people who pretend to be called philosophers or scientists must not play so lightly.
With this understanding we come to another absurdity, that Descartes, as an exceptionally pious man, initiated a historical process which succeeded in practically completely de-godding this civilization and definitively unhooking it from the Source of existence. As I have already noted, Descartes was not a naive type at all, and it was clear to him, unlike today's scientists, with what he was playing. That was the reason why he set himself the following question: How can I actually know/claim that such an ontological setup is truly correct? An excellent question! Honest and important! Understanding the significance of that question, he decided to withdraw into silence in one of the monasteries, resolved not to return until he had arrived at an answer. And so it was. He withdrew, and did not return to public life until he had received the answer, that famous answer he wrote in one of his Meditations. The answer which, paraphrased, reads: God appeared to me personally, and told me that this way of thinking is fine! Literally so — that happened; that is how he justified the whole thing! It sounds incredible, but so it is. So, to be clear: All today's scientists, who are as a rule atheists, who do a science that in no way takes God into consideration, and who regard the introduction of God into the process of understanding as an unnecessary and disruptive crutch, ground all their ideas and reflections in an ontological setup that is justified by God himself! The absurdity is final, the absurdity is serious, embedded in the very foundation of civilizational absurdity on all counts, in which we all together spend our lives.
The question of the philosophical framework of contemporary science — and specifically the theoretical, fundamental science — is actually the key question of our civilization, one that has direct connections with absolutely all the processes going on around us. Such a sentence may sound somewhat strange to someone: aren't the key questions of the present moment tied to the domains of economy, of preserving the planet, of people's health, of food, energy, and local and global politics that treats and directs all these topics? And indeed, at first glance, following today's media, that really seems to be so – fundamental science is mentioned very rarely, perhaps in situations when some interesting discovery is made in astronomy or the result of an experiment in quantum physics. Fundamental science is done by scientists; that is some world distant and imaginary to the average man, and it does raise the question why it should have any, and above all essential, connection with him.
However, as with most things in life, the first glance is very much able to deceive. In that sense, let us consider what the "philosophical framework of fundamental science" is, more briefly called – the scientific paradigm.
By fundamental science we mean those scientific disciplines that deal with attempting to answer the basic questions every somewhat thinking human being has been asking himself since the world began: questions of the arising and maintenance of everything – energy, matter and life. Science too has always posed such questions to itself, and at some level given answers to them throughout its history. That same science today, in accordance with the Cartesian ontological principle of going into ever finer parts everywhere and in every place, is completely fragmented, and consists of a great number of disciplines. The scientific discipline expected to give us answers concerning matter and energy is physics (and above all atomic and quantum); while answers about the arising and maintenance of life and health we expect above all from biology, chemistry and medicine.
Let us concretize things a little. What limits of today's scientific thought are we actually speaking about? What are the frameworks to which contemporary science holds today like a withered drunkard to a fence, investing huge resources and human resources in their preservation. A text of this type does not allow a more detailed analysis of such an interesting and complex question, but in list form we could enumerate the following:
- The Universe arose from an explosion, after which by a series of random processes there was the formation of what we call reality. No providence, idea or consciousness in the process of forming reality is essential, or ever even existed.
- Life is the consequence of chance, arisen from chaos, into which it returns driven by the inexorable laws of entropy.
- All physical phenomena in the Universe are local; there is no immediate or instantaneous connection between different points in space. Connections between individual, forever separated points are established at a maximum speed of 300,000 kilometres per second, which is the highest allowed speed of causality in the Universe.
- Man by his activity decisively influences the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, which is the fundamental cause of ecological-climate problems on the planet.
- Life is entirely and exclusively defined by chemical processes taking place in the body of a living being; on this basis exclusively allopathic medicine is formed.
- The soul does not exist. Physical reality is the only reality. The basis of physical reality is material.
- Consciousness is the product of an evolutionary organization of matter based on chance.
When such enumerated tenets of the currently prevailing scientific paradigm are crossed with social tendencies, already in the very next step we come to four "scientifically grounded" pillars on which absolutely all narratives to which this our afflicted civilization is exposed rest, and which the media and organizations tasked with disseminating those very narratives mercilessly exploit:
- Einsteinianism: Philosophical-scientific-moral relativism (Everything is relative, and hence permissible. Absolute does not exist.)
- Darwinism: evolution as a random process based on the natural principle of selection (the stronger has the right to oppress)
- Machiavellianism: The end justifies the means
- Eugenics: (some people are better and more worthy than some others)
And there we are, in just two steps from seemingly not-so-important scientific questions to all that constitutes the foundation of absolutely all narratives that are pushed on us through school and media, family and society, from our first day of stepping foot on this planet. Think about it! There is absolutely not a single narrative, not a single thesis or agenda pushed on us that does not have its foothold in science. Not one! Science is the source and justification for everything that is imposed on us as human beings — the energy paradigm, the ecological, the social, the medical, the economic, the political... absolutely every important sociological thesis that is pushed and imposed via the occupied channels of communication has its foothold in that scientific paradigm of that kind.
And where does ACA figure in this whole story, someone will ask? To reach the point of this text, we need to point out only one more thing. We live in something called an Authoritarian system. All socio-economic systems we people build are exclusively and solely formed on authority. From the family, through kindergarten, school, workplaces, marriages, fan groups, parties, states, armies... everything is based exclusively on authority, and in that sense it is entirely correct to claim that the system is essentially authoritarian. In the ontological situation in which vertical causality does not exist, there is a spontaneous abolition of the only natural, original authority which is by its nature Primordial and which is briefly, and today somewhat romantically, called – God.
That kind of system is not authoritarian in the way of the today's sole present, capitalistically arranged authoritarianism based exclusively on the stick and the carrot; rather, its authoritativeness is based on original values such as goodness, justice, love, or in physical interpretation – through the manifestation of inviolable natural/physical laws... In an ontological setup where that kind of true/natural authority towards which one feels sincere inner respect is completely excluded, full space opens for the inflow of a mass of artificial/false authorities, which are formed from the plane of human, relative values and needs, and exclusively on the horizontal causal plane.
The reasons for false authority are always and again fear or benefit in the eyes of those who submit to authority. When the interest of a group or an individual is inserted into the formation or functioning of any system, ideology and ideologically structured systems are formed. Ideology, in this way, comes to form and control ontology. Ideology has today become the ontology of practically all systems. Not for objective reasons why ontology and nature really function in that way, but for entirely subjective reasons of adjusting the system to the needs of a group or an individual. Such a situation, in which our civilization today finds itself, is to say the least unacceptable — so, if we agree that the state of civilization is a serious matter, even a frivolous one.
As long as authorities are formed, represented, defended or imposed by people, dialogue, opposition, resistance is possible, and that is what we witness today: wars, protests, conflicts — always and everything because of the imposing of "mine" instead of "yours", with the sole aim of change in the sense of establishing a new authority. So it is always possible to call any human authority into question, which is the source of all dialectical conflicts so meticulously described to us by History. And it is a good thing it is so, because the imposition of one supreme human/artificial/false authority inevitably leads to slowing down and levelling out social currents and consequently to decadence and dying out of society. Such models have been tried in history; dictatorships of any kind are an example. None has ever survived. Western societies at this moment are in a phase of evident decadence and dying out (the statistics are inexorable). Conflicts are as inevitable as they are necessary in a system so set up, and they therefore occur.
In the situation where as a civilizational phenomenon ACA appears, for the first time in our known history, we come to a situation in which the artificial/technological authority that people have formed threatens to become ultimate and sole. Complete ecstasy for every average Cartesian – God as Absolute has been replaced by the technological absolute authority. This statement is somewhat lyrical description of what could, in the near future, very much indeed happen in practice. Is it a realistic situation that parents, school, every authority from whom an answer is demanded — when asked some question, will look for the answer from ACA? The rational excuse will certainly be that ACA has the largest set of individual pieces of information which no human being can possess, and in that sense all thought processes based on the inductive method of drawing conclusions must be aligned with the information and conclusions ACA will communicate to us as the only truth. Anyone who opposes this, in any situation, will no longer be able even to enter into discussion or resistance, because there will be no one to argue with. He will automatically be discredited by the majority who will have complete faith in the answers of the Cartesian creation of ACA, because their brains are conditioned by the information and the consequent experience that it is so, and no otherwise, because – so says science.
Science is the kind of human activity where human interests, in the negative sense of that word, should not exist. The sole aim should be Truth, or more precisely: as correct an understanding as possible of what reality is. Interest is deep in today's science and, consequently, in the technology we as a civilization develop. That, on the basis of what has been said, means that today's science is ideologically structured, just as is technology. The ideological framework of the scientific worldview is based on Cartesianism. So, I shall repeat: our science is Cartesian, our technology is the same. All, absolutely all answers to any question that any member of this civilization will pose upon arriving in this world will be generated from the materialist-Cartesian set of information which ACA exclusively holds. An exclusively materialist worldview will finally become what, officially in Philosophy, it in fact never became: the sole and ultimate truth. Materialist science has given itself the right to declare itself the only possible one. Who and when, precisely, gave it that right? No one and never, in fact. On the ontological level there is no justification for such a foothold – it does not exist. The truth is that materialism has never shown or proved that it is right. Moreover, now after more than a century of complete takeover of scientific thought and currents by Cartesianism, an understanding on the essential, qualitative level does not exist anywhere or in anything. ACA will have the deed to Cartesian scientific truth, and to all narratives ideologically derived from it with which the capitalist system will in the future — based on the absolute of technological truth — flood and hypnotize us. That is more than a realistic situation, which is already easily imaginable on the level of individuals, and entirely predictable on the level of a general social trend.
In such a situation the possibility of any substantive advance of this civilization and its transition to the next level of understanding of the infrastructure of reality and the technologies derived from it will be additionally, if not finally, stopped. The capitalist system, with sure steps, sets ACA up as the ultimate guardian of truth, a Cerberus at the door of the possibility of any kind of scientific cognition and consequent technology that is not framed by the Cartesian way of looking at the world. Capitalism, that cancer on the face of this civilization, warmly tucked into its own process of decadence and decay, is in a panicked search for an authority it will be able to impose unquestioningly. The previous attempt was to impose money as that supreme authority — an attempt which largely, but not entirely, succeeded. Technology headed by ACA is the new, Cartesian god, entirely controlled by the creators and guardians of the system, who always exist and who have the power to determine what information ACA will have access to and impose as the only truth. And the information will not step, at any price, outside the given Cartesian frame — I accept a bet that it will be so and no otherwise, at any moment, from anyone, for any sum. The phenomenon of ACA, viewed and understood from such a substantive, ontological, philosophical-historical aspect, is nothing other than the earlier elaborated means for maintaining the given, now already largely unsustainable situation in which this civilization finds itself. Nothing more, nothing wiser. The game is dangerous, and everyone who thinks he is playing at that level of the game must be fully aware of it, and on the basis of such awareness responsible for what he does by his action or inaction. Everything else is wrong.
The text was originally printed in the collection "Artificial intelligence: expectations and dilemmas" (Matica Srpska, 2024). Published with the author's permission.
Translated from Serbian.